MP60s vs S58s

[chasm]

Toplines and head size suprises

I was for the first time able to compare my MP 60s against my S58s and was surprised by the differences anf how my perceptions were wrong.

MP60s have a thinner topline.

MP60s short irons look like shovels

S 58 long irons look like shovels (yet lack of offset make them look powerful)

MP60 soles are fatter (marginal)

Overall, it confirms why I am happy that the S58s are my main set but it got me wondering about what is important as regards club aethetics.

Very thin top line if possible. Compact short irons (Titleist may do this better than most other OEMs). Some degree of confidence on the longer irons - be it top line thickness or sole width or whatever.

I say I was surprised - I had the S58s pegged as the more compact clubs all round

Have you had any preconceptions about clubs that were shown to be wrong when doing a side-by-side comparison?

[igman]

Last year, I switched from MP60's to S58's, which was supposed to be a stop gap until I ordered the MP57's. Never did order them, now I am considering ordering S57's...but am not sure I can like irons more than the current 58's. Of course, this could all change next week, but over a year with these and still loving them. I do miss the Mizzy feel, from what I remember :rolleyes: